Hello dear
Welcome To Gene McCarthy's
"Gene McCarthy's, located in Buffalo, NY, is a charming American brewery and pub offering a cozy atmosphere and a diverse menu. Known for its delicious handhelds and vegetarian options, this iconic spot is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The beer selection, brewed in-house, is a standout feature, with unique flavors like Gene's Lager and Razzputon Raspberry Ale. The food, from the Rachel sandwich to the Beef on Weck, is consistently fresh and flavorful. With friendly service and a welcoming environment, Gene McCarthy's is a must-visit destination for a true Buffalo dining experience."
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Gene McCarthy's
Gene McCarthy's, nestled in Buffalo's Old First Ward, is a true gem for those seeking authentic American cuisine with a twist. This historic tavern pays homage to its roots with a cozy atmosphere adorned with memorabilia, creating a nostalgic ambiance. The highlight of Gene McCarthy's lies in their handcrafted beers, each sip revealing the dedication and skill put into their brewing process.
Their diverse menu caters to all tastes, with options ranging from traditional handhelds like the Reuben sandwich and chicken wings to more unique offerings such as Ahi Tuna salad and Souvlaki salad. Vegetarian options are plentiful, ensuring that everyone at the table finds something to indulge in.
Customer reviews rave about the quality and flavors of the dishes, with standout items like the Sheffield Wings with a dry rub, Stuffed Banana Peppers filled with three cheeses, and the classic beef on weck sandwich. The attention to detail in the preparation and presentation of each dish truly shines through, leaving patrons coming back for more.
As a food enthusiast, I can attest to the sheer delight of dining at Gene McCarthy's. The beer flight offers a diverse range of flavors, from the crisp Gene's Lager to the robust Wake the Dead coffee stout. The culinary experience is elevated by their impeccable service and charming ambiance, making it a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.
In conclusion, Gene McCarthy's is more than just a restaurant; it's a culinary haven where history meets innovation, and each bite tells a story of passion and creativity. Whether you're looking for a casual lunch spot or a place to unwind with friends over a few beers, Gene McCarthy's is sure to exceed your expectations.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ This is a lovely little brewery wrapped into a cozy local corner pub. We brought the kids and enjoyed the last half of a playoff game. There was a broad kids menu including vegetarian options. The menu is heavy on handhelds, again with vegetarian options. Our beer flight highlighted a solid beer backbone: the red, porter and pale ale were the best for us. We especially appreciated the kitchen was open later on a Sunday. While we live out of town, I anticipate we will be back! ”
“ Came here for lunch on a Saturday and was seated right away. The waitress was friendly and attentive. I ordered the Rachel sandwich, French onion soup and hot wings. The food came out quickly and it was all piping hot and fresh. Everything was delicious! I especially loved the hot sauce on the wings, it was the perfect amount of spice and flavor. The sandwich was piled high with turkey and the French onion soup was probably one of the best that I've had. ”
“ This place is iconic south Buffalo. A brewery and awesome food. My usual go-tos are the Ahi Tuna salad, Reuben, chicken wings or fingers, Souvlaki salad. But everything is fantastic. The servers are friendly and the service is great. It's not a huge place and can get busy at lunch. Definitely a place to try if you've never been! ”
“ Stopped by with our dogs for an outdoor lunch on a beautiful fall afternoon. A server came out promptly with menus and took our orders. Water bowl already out for the pups and self-serve cold water available at the window to the bar. I had Reuben with side salad and hubby had fish tacos. Unique and delicious mandarin orange salad dressing. Reuben was more like a panini, grilled and squished together. It was good but could have used a little more corned beef. Tacos were an order of 2 with a great deal of cole slaw, pickled onions and radishes, but a fairly small piece of cajun grilled fish on each. If you're really hungry, I suggest you order something else. ”
“ Located in Buffalo's Old First Ward (OFW), this historic tavern sits in what used to be a bustling epicenter. Irish workers found jobs by the Buffalo waterfront. As soon as you walk in, you can look in any direction to see that every space on the walls and ceilings adorned with memorabilia like pictures, tools, old flyers, even a kayak or row boat. What makes this place special is that they brew their own beers. I loved every one I tried, we took some home. Here's what we ordered: - beer flight: Gene's Lager (my fave), streaker IPA, Razzputon (raspberry ale), Against the Grain and Wake the dead (coffee stout) - Sheffield Wings (dry rub) - Stuffed Banana Peppers - banana peppers stuffed with 3 cheeses, with grilled pita wedges - beef on weck: slow roasted to medium rare, sliced thin, dipped in au jus, piled on top of fresh toasted kimmelweck roll We ended up taking home these beers: - Ipso Facto - Gene's Lager - Chill Everything we ordered was so good. When it came time to pick our favorite spot, Gene's was our top pick when it came to our buffalo wing adventure. This place had everything. Great beer, best sheffield wings, best stuffed peps and the beef on weck. We felt that Gene McCarthy's had the best authentic experience. Highly recommend. ”
“ Definitely has the feel of a neighborhood bar that's been around since 1933. The only unusual additions were high top tables, but given the lack of floor space, this makes sense. The pints were good and the food was great! We had the sampler plate which came with wings and a mini Beef on Kimmilwick. The roll had way too much salt on it, but it was easy enough to scrape off the extra. Could have used a cup of au jus to dip the sandwich in, but I wasn't complaining. All in all a decent spot for lunch. ”
“ This is a warm, cozy, friendly neighborhood pub with good food and beer. There is such a relaxed vibe here that makes you feel right at home. The servers treated us like we were family, which I loved. The food arrived quickly and was hot and tasty. We came for the live jazz music on a Monday night in February. Alex McArthur and Company were phenomenal. ”
